Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Class III & More
  • Gear
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
  • News
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • People
    • Podcasts
    • Rides
    • Survival
    • Tactics & Training
  • VIDEOS
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Class III & More
  • Gear
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
  • News
  • Lifestyle
    • Culture
    • People
    • Podcasts
    • Rides
    • Survival
    • Tactics & Training
  • VIDEOS
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
No Result
View All Result
 
New Year, New FREE GUN FRIDAY! Enter to WIN the Smith & Wesson and Black Hills package.

The Sandy Hook Settlement and What it Really Means for Gun Companies

Will Dabbs MD by Will Dabbs MD
February 18, 2022
in Culture, Lifestyle
0
The Sandy Hook settlement sets up troublesome precedent for civil action.
0
SHARES
49
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Do we really want to go here? Are Americans ready to allow civil lawsuits to go forward against the manufacturers of legal products specifically protected by the U.S. Constitution when they are used in illegal ways? The recent Sandy Hook settlement does just that.

Bushmaster XM15-E2S, Connecticut Supreme Court, Sandy Hook Massacre
RELATED STORY

Connecticut Supreme Court: Remington Can Be Sued For Sandy Hook

Sandy Hook Settlement: The Big Picture

Trial attorneys representing the families of nine of the twenty-six victims of the unimaginably horrific Sandy Hook shootings have finally wheedled the now-defunct Remington Outdoor Company’s insurers out of a $73 million settlement. When the deranged lunatic Adam Lanza walked into the Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012, he carried his murdered mother’s Bushmaster XM15-E2S rifle as well as her Glock 20SF handgun. Remington Outdoor Company, which has since declared bankruptcy twice and sold off in pieces to new ownerships, was then the parent company of Bushmaster. The subsequent lawsuit spanned a full eight years.

The 2005 Federal Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act exists to prevent just such cataclysmic legal actions. However, by drilling down into Bushmaster’s marketing practices using Connecticut’s Unfair Trade Practices Act, attorneys for the plaintiffs took the suit through the Connecticut state legal system and all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. SCOTUS then refused to hear the case. In the face of astronomical legal costs, Remington’s insurers finally settled. Never mind the fact the plaintiffs provided no evidence that Bushmaster marketing influenced Nancy Lanza, or for that matter Adam Lanza, in any way. Of course, Adam Lanza stole the rifle, a criminal act.

Anti-gun activists are metaphorically dancing in the streets. Like most seismic shifts in the Information Age culture wars, the devil is in the details. Could this settlement really change everything?

Love it or hate it, the AR-15 is the most popular rifle in America. There are untold millions in circulation. Countless bankers, custodians, teachers, truck drivers, physicians, and garbage men legally own one of these efficient little weapons. Some of us own several. What this settlement proves is that plaintiff’s attorneys can claw vast sums of money out of a corporation not because their product was innately defective or irresponsibly designed. Remington’s insurers paid $73 million because someone who did not have legal access to their gun used it to do a patently illegal thing. This sets a simply breathtaking precedent.

The Problem

Sandy Hook was viscerally repugnant no matter your political bent. Adam Lanza shot and killed his mother, took her firearms, and then blasted his way through an elementary school. This soulless monster brutally murdered 27 people, most of them children, before killing himself. Reading the sanitized description on Wikipedia made me feel a bit ill.

When faced with such horrific carnage it is only natural to seek out a villain. Adam Lanza was the obvious target, but he blew his own miserable brains out. The bereaved parents subsequently focused their rage on the gun industry.

The Scope

For those touched by Adam Lanza’s rampage this is literally unimaginably horrible. As a parent myself I honestly cannot imagine. However, there is an issue of scale.

Per the FBI, in 2012 14,827 reported murders occurred in America. Of those, 322 killings involved a rifle of any sort. During the same timeframe, 678 murderers killed with their hands and feet, while another 518 used blunt weapons like hammers and clubs. 

As difficult as it is to hear, the tool Adam Lanza used to commit his atrocity was no different from the hammer or tire iron some other evil person might have chosen. That Bushmaster AR-15 was not designed or marketed to kill children any more than a hammer is intended as a close combat weapon. And therein lies the problem.

The Precedent

The U.S. Constitution protects the individual right of Americans to bear arms just as it protects our rights to speak freely, protest the government, and attend church. Like it or not, the right to keep and bear arms is one of the most revered in the American experience. What this recent lawsuit establishes is that the tools required to exercise this sacred right are now subject to catastrophic civil litigation. A parallel might be if the government claimed to respect freedom of the press but allowed the manufacturers of high-volume printing presses to be sued into bankruptcy.

Remington did not admit guilt as part of the settlement. Admitting guilt is not the point. The point is to use the American justice system as a cudgel to destroy a legal business. That and to make trial attorneys filthy rich.

Plaintiff’s attorneys typically keep between 33 and 40% of the final take. In this case, attorneys for the plaintiffs likely took home around $26 million. They call it the Big Lick. That’s the way the system works.

Josh Koskoff, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said, “This victory should serve as a wake-up call not only to the gun industry, but also the insurance and banking companies that prop it up…Our hope is that this victory will be the first boulder in the avalanche that forces that change.”

President Joe Biden subsequently urged state and local lawmakers, plaintiff’s attorneys, and survivors of gun violence, “To pursue efforts to replicate the success of the Sandy Hook families.” Meanwhile, a simple truth remains: the responsibility for crimes – no matter how horrific – belongs with the criminals.

It’s About the Money

What if Adam Lanza had chosen to use a car, a propane cylinder, or gasoline? In each case these would have been legal items illegally utilized. Now an enterprising plaintiff’s attorney could conceivably sue the manufacturers of all this stuff if they alleged that the company’s marketing scheme did not adequately dissuade illegal behavior.

Those ubiquitous billboards with the big grinning trial attorneys cost about $500 per month down here in Mississippi. They are markedly more expensive elsewhere. Countless thousands of these things grace America’s motorways from sea to shining sea. Somebody has to pay for all that.

Given this monumental precedent there is now little to keep plaintiff’s attorneys from using this backdoor template to sue ammunition and gun manufacturers whenever criminals egregiously misuse their products. Over time expect some companies to fold and all those fresh costs to be passed on to consumers. This will make it all the more expensive and difficult to exercise our 2nd Amendment rights. But that was, of course, the point.

Editor’s Note: NSSF Statement

A statement released by the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) put the Sandy Hook settlement into clear view. It points out the settlement came from outside the firearms industry. Insurance companies, representing a now-defunct company, elected to settle. No industry company ever made an admission of any guilt. Further, NSSF says the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act endures, offering protection to gun companies. Read the entire statement in our coverage on Tactical Life.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

CLICK HERE FOR COMMENTS

RELATED POSTS

Parkwest Arms looks to continue on the legacy of the famed Dakota Arms.

Parkwest Arms Builds on Dakota Arms Legacy of High-End Rifle Builds

field, binoculars, silencer, rifle, animals

Pittman-Robertson Passes $14 Billion in Wildlife Restoration Contributions

Highest-Selling Guns in 2020, 2020 gun sales

NSSF Releases Data on Highest-Selling Guns So Far in 2020

Bushmaster XM15-E2S, Connecticut Supreme Court, Sandy Hook Massacre

Connecticut Supreme Court: Remington Can Be Sued For Sandy Hook

Load More

WATCH NOW: Night Shooter | Season 2

Discussion about this post

FEATURED POST

Ballistic's Best Reader's Choice Winners

Winners Announced: Ballistic’s Best Readers’ Choice 2022

The votes are in! We've counted the ballots, and we're excited and impressed by you, the...

Read more

TRENDING

7 new products announced ahead of shot show 2023.

New Guns & Gear Launched at SHOT Show 2023

A top-quality chassis gives you adjustability and other features you need to make your long-range shooting more accurate and fun. These 7 top rifle chassis do it with class.

7 Top Rifle Chassis That Add Class & Accuracy to Your Long-Range Shoot

We tested 12 compact and micro compact pistols to determine the best carry gun.

Best Concealed Carry Pistols 2022: Compacts & Micros Dominate

Affordable Precision Rifles 2018

19 Affordable Precision Rifles That Won’t Break the Bank

PICK A CATEGORY

TRAINING & TACTICS SPOTLIGHT

The SecureIt Retrofit Kit helps organize gun safe storage.

DIY Upgrade With the SecureIt Gun Storage Steel 6 Gun Safe Retrofit Kit

Like many of you, my gun collection consists of more than one gun. In fact, it is significantly more than...

SHOWCASE: TRAINING AND TACTICS

Clearing Corners Gunsite Academy lead

10 Key Tips to Clearing Corners That May Save Your Ass

Chris Hemsworth learns box breathing and other challenges in Limitless.

Use Box Breathing Like Chris Hemsworth to Calm Down & Make The Shot

zeroing in rifles and pistols

Zeroing Rifles & Pistols: Getting to & Maintaining Zeroed Sights

European Mount, DIY Euro Mount, Hunting, lead

How to Make a European Mount in 6 Steps

Team SIG Sauer's Lena Miculek fires a P365 and debates .380 vs 9mm.

VIDEO: SIG Sauer’s Lena Miculek Debates .380 Vs 9mm for Defense

Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting, pistol

The Guide to Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting

Follow this guide to better shooting on the move.

SHOOTING 101: 3 Keys to Getting Hits While Shooting on the Move

Understanding eye dominance and both eyes open shooting will help you get on target.

VIDEO: Understanding Eye Dominance for Better Accuracy & Speed

AMMO SPOTLIGHT

Hornady Subsonic 7.62x39 launches a 255-grain bullet.

Hornady Subsonic 7.62×39 Ammunition Launches 255-grain Bullet, Quietly!

Hornady just announced the release of a very interesting new load, one we think hunters will jump all over....

site logo
The Premier Firearms & Survival Magazine

Tactical

  • tactical-life.com

Magazines

  • Tactical Life
  • The Complete Book of Reloading
  • Guns of the Old West

Facebook

  • Tactical-Life Facebook
  • Guns of the Old West Facebook

Twitter

  • Tactical-Life Twitter

Self Defense

  • PersonalDefenseWorld.com

Magazines

  • Personal Defense World
  • Combat Handguns

Facebook

  • Personal Defense World Facebook
  • Combat Handguns

Twitter

  • Personal Defense World Twitter

Shooting Lifestyle

  • BallisticMag.com

Magazines

  • Ballistic Magazine

Facebook

  • Ballistic Magazine Facebook

Twitter

  • Ballistic Magazine Twitter

Alpha Lifestyle

  • SkillsetMag.com

Magazines

  • Skillset

Facebook

  • Skillset Magazine Facebook

Twitter

  • Skillset Magazine Twitter

Instagram

  • Skillset Magazine Instagram
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Terms Of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • California Privacy Notice
  • Cookie Policy
© Athlon Outdoors, All Rights Reserved.
You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and awareness of the California Privacy Rights. Pursuant to U.S. Copyright law, as well as other applicable federal and state laws, the content on this website may not be reproduced, distributed, displayed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, without the prior, express, and written permission of Athlon Outdoors.

Manage your GDPR consents by clicking here. Manage your CCPA consents by clicking here.
No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • View All Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Class III & More
    • Sponsored
      • SIG Sauer
  • Gear
    • View All Gear
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
  • Videos
  • More
    • Free Gun Friday Sweeps
    • Sweepstakes
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
  • News
  • Lifestyle
    • View All Lifestyle
    • Tactics & Training
    • Survival
    • People
    • Podcasts
    • Rides

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.