Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Bolt Action
      • Lever Action
    • Shotguns
    • Specialty Guns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • Knives
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
    • Concealed Carry
    • Survival
    • Training
  • News
  • VIDEOS
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Bolt Action
      • Lever Action
    • Shotguns
    • Specialty Guns
    • Airguns
    • Custom Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
  • Accessories
    • Optics & Sights
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • Knives
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • Sport Shooting
      • Hunting
    • Precision Shooting/Long Range Shooting
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
    • Concealed Carry
    • Survival
    • Training
  • News
  • VIDEOS
  • Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
No Result
View All Result
 
*FREE GUN FRIDAY* Enter to WIN >> IWI Zion-15 Rifle & Black Hills 5.56 Ammo

AR Build: 7 Myths & Building the Rifle the Internet Said Was ‘Impossible’

Graham Baates by Graham Baates
March 2, 2021
in Guns, Rifles
0
AR Build, Cheap AR Build, lead
0
SHARES
658
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A while back I happened upon a deal for a set of F1 receivers that I could not refuse. Already owning several ARs in various calibers and configurations, those receivers soon left me with the question of what to build next. The inspiration came for an experiment that tests common opinion of what an AR can do. I personally purchased all of the parts for this AR build. I never meant to show this off in media. It was just a fun project, at first. It simply evolved into a social experiment and now grounds for discussion.

Unique ARs, AR-15 Build, Pacific Northwest
RELATED STORY

VIDEO: A Pacific Northwest-Themed Unique ARs Build With Patriotism

The Impossible AR Build

Initial struggles led me to post a YouTube video about it. The comments on that video told me that there are a lot of misconceptions about the AR platform out there, as more than 3,000 comments could essentially be boiled down into seven individual myths as to why my rifle build was impossible. 

Take a look at the build list and see if any components, or the mixture thereof, stick out in your mind as parts or pieces never meant to be used together. I included links to the products I used where possible:

My AR Build List

  • Receivers: F-1 Firearms UDR-15 3G
  • Handguard: F-1 Firearms H7M Ultra Light Handguard
  • Barrel: Aero Precision 18-inch fluted, rifle-length gas
  • Muzzle Device: Vendetta Precision VP-09 Interceptor Muzzle Brake in Titanium
  • Gas Block: Patriot Ordnance Factory Dictator Adjustable Gas Block
  • Bolt-Carrier Group: DSA Arms Enhanced low Mass Aluminum Sand Cut Bolt Carrier Group
  • Trigger: RISE Armament Patriot Trigger
  • Buffer: Odin Works Adjustable Buffer AR15 Lite
  • Buffer Tube: Primary Weapons Systems Enhanced Buffer Tube (carbine length)
  • Stock: Luth-AR MBA-4

The Goal of My AR Build

The goal was to make the rifle as soft-shooting as possible. I was going for silly-soft at the risk of reliability and intended to adjust the gas settings and buffer weight to achieve that. A rifle-length gas system and reduced reciprocating mass would serve as the core of a soft-shooting rifle.  The first range trip was problematic as the rifle wouldn’t always complete a cycle. Sometimes it would eject the spent case, but not pick up the next round, other times it failed to eject.

Before going into the steps I took to remedy this, let’s take a look at why the Internet said the gun couldn’t work and explore where there might have been validity, as well as reality.

The Myths of Rifle Building

Now onto the actual myths I tried to disprove here.

Myth 1: An 18-inch barrel with rifle-length gas can’t work

AR Build Step 1, barrel
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

The theory here is that there isn’t enough dwell time. That is to say that the time pressure is still blocked behind the projectile and being pushed into the gas system is too short. This is thought because there is only ____ of barrel between the gas block and the muzzle. The effect is exacerbated by an already long gas system, which naturally results in lower pressure hitting the bolt carrier. Though the initial ARs used the long, rifle-length gas system, many builders have shied away from it in recent trends. Why? Shorter gas systems increase reliability with a stronger punch of gas pressure to the carrier.

Reality: While a rifle-length system provides less pressure and for a shorter duration, it remains a viable and common application. A gas system this long on a relatively short barrel does present the opportunity for challenges. However, it has been proven practical enough that even mainstream barrels makers—such as my chosen Aero Precision—offer them.

Myth 2: Gas block exposed

AR Build Step 2, gas block
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

I surmise the theory is that by exposing the gas block it’s too easily bumped. For my build I wanted easy access to the gas block. 

Reality: The first AR used an exposed gas block, as did the M16A2 I took to Afghanistan and again to Iraq. The military compensates for rough use by pinning the gas block. However, as this rifle is not intended for hard use and abuse, a set-screw positioned in a dimple is ample retention.

Myth 3: Gas block is clamping on flutes

AR Build Step 3, clamping
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

The theory here is that the gas black isn’t able to clamp strongly enough to the barrel or seal completely.

Reality: The length of the Patriot Ordnance Factory Dictator gas block is deceiving. The block only has one pickup point toward the rear of the block. Meanwhile, the barrel isn’t fluted in that section. The forward clamp rests on flutes, but those flutes are the same diameter as the gas journal. While I lose surface area, clamping force remains and the front clamp is ancillary, not primary.

Myth 4: F-1 Receivers are venting too much gas

AR Build Step 4, receivers
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

Many feared that such open receivers were permitting gas to flow too easily, resulting in a loss of pressure needed to cycle the rifle.

Reality: The AR receiver plays no role in containing gas pressure for the purpose of cycling.  Gas travels from the tube into the key, presses against the tail of the bolt (that part that always gets so dirty) and vents out the sides of the carrier.

Myth 5: An aluminum BCG doesn’t have enough inertia or momentum

Step 5, Aluminum BCG
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

If the carrier is too light, it won’t be able to act against the buffer’s weight or spring tension. The DSA BCG weighs 5.2 ounces compared to a standard steel BCG weighing 11.6 ounces.

Reality: There is some validity to this. The functioning of the rifle depends on a balance between gas pressure, carrier weight, buffer weight, and spring tension. This build began with an adjustable buffer for that reason. The overall weight of this build’s buffer and BCG is 6.7 ounces; compare that to a standard BCG and H buffer with an overall weight of 15.4 ounces. This build’s reciprocating mass is only 43 percent of “the norm.”

Myth 6: Not Using a Buffer Retaining Pin

Step 6, Buffer Retaining Pin
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

Comments were that without the buffer retaining pin, there would be constant pressure on the bolt carrier. In turn, people said this would resist its efforts to move. Either that or that without a pin to stop the buffer, it would travel too far forward into the upper receiver and interfere with the hammer.

Reality: The buffer retaining pin serves only as a convenience for rifle take down. If you open your rifle you’ll note that the carrier fills the upper receiver nearly completely in its forward-most position. It’s simply not possible for the buffer or spring to extend any further into the upper receiver. In this receiver set, the retaining pin is threaded in using a tiny Allen key that I did not want to have to mess with to adjust the buffer, so I simply left the pin out of the build.

Myth 7: Rifle-Length gas with carbine-length buffer tube

Step 7, carbine-length buffer tube
(Photo by Teya Freeman)

Concerns stem from the idea that a buffer spring’s rate is set based on the amount of weight and force that will be acting against it. For example, a carbine buffer tube would require a carbine spring (higher rate than a rifle spring per inch of length), standard buffer, and standard bolt carrier weight expecting carbine-length gas impulse.

Reality: This myth could have been true if the build wasn’t using a reduced-weight carrier and buffer to compensate for the relatively soft gas impulse. Exceptions do of course exist, especially with the tendency of barrel makers to be a little generous with their gas port sizes to help increase reliability. But I countered this potential by using an adjustable-weight lightweight buffer.

Making It Possible

The Internet suggested enlarging the barrel’s gas port, changing barrels, changing gas system lengths, and even buying a suppressor—and waiting for its approval—to make the rifle run. The solution was much easier and less expensive than any of those suggestions. I picked up a reduce-power recoil spring for $20. Now the rifle runs without issue.  With the adjustable buffer empty, I’m able to tune the gas system for a silky-smooth rifle that either runs only 5.56x45mm, or with one click on the gas block will also run the lower-pressured .223 Remington.

Posting the original video turned into a great social experiment. Those commenting demonstrated their knowledge (or lack thereof) of the AR platform. Also, quite a few exhibited a fear and hatred of the unknown or those who dare to be different. The original recipe for the AR still works today, as do the trend-builds of using shorter-than-needed gas systems to increase reliability.

My build was the result of growing tired of “just another” AR. I was looking to experiment. In the end, it turned out wonderfully. Also, a special thanks to Cascadian Gunwerks of McMinnville, Ore., for its support in this “impossible” build via Cerakoting, assembly of the upper receiver and proper alignment of the gas block verified with a Hawkeye Borescope.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

CLICK HERE FOR COMMENTS

RELATED POSTS

Barrett MRAD SMR Rifle Review, right

VIDEO: Shooting the Barrett MRAD SMR – Single Mission Rifle

Savage Arms introduces a dozen rifles chambered in 400 Legend.

Savage Launches Several Rifles Chambered in 400 Legend

The J.P. Sauer 100 LWT rifle.

J.P. SAUER 100 LWT, Pantera XT Rifles Add H-S Precision Stocks

The ZEV Core Combat rifle series.

ZEV Core Combat: New Rifle Series Brings Duty-Grade Platform

Load More

WATCH NOW: Long Range Precision

Discussion about this post

FEATURED POST

Ballistic's Best Reader's Choice Winners

Winners Announced: Ballistic’s Best Readers’ Choice 2022

The votes are in! We've counted the ballots, and we're excited and impressed by you, the...

Read more

TRENDING

All the best new handguns seen at SHOT Show 2023.

New for 2023: The 21 Best New Handguns Seen at SHOT Show

Best Glock Trigger Upgrades, Glock triggers

Best Aftermarket Glock Triggers [2023]

300 Blackout vs 308, rifles, ammunition

300 Blackout vs 308 Win: Which Round Reigns Supreme in AR-15s?

10 of the greatest pistol trainers and gunfighters

TOP 10: The Best Shooting Instructors & Gunfighters of All-Time

PICK A CATEGORY

TRAINING & TACTICS SPOTLIGHT

Ball and Buck Jack Carr Special Edition shirt.

NEW THREADS: Ball and Buck X Jack Carr Limited Edition Shirt

Ball and Buck just announced a new clothing item in partnership with one of our favorite pro-gun fiction writers. The...

SHOWCASE: TRAINING AND TACTICS

DIY Backyard Shooting Range, clearing land, bulldozer

How to Build a Backyard Shooting Range for Under $2,000

One-Handed Shooting, One Handed Shooting, Single Handed Shooting, lead

Ballistic’s Guide to One-Handed Shooting

Clearing Corners Gunsite Academy lead

10 Key Tips to Clearing Corners That May Save Your Ass

Chris Hemsworth learns box breathing and other challenges in Limitless.

Use Box Breathing Like Chris Hemsworth to Calm Down & Make The Shot

zeroing in rifles and pistols

Zeroing Rifles & Pistols: Getting to & Maintaining Zeroed Sights

European Mount, DIY Euro Mount, Hunting, lead

How to Make a European Mount in 6 Steps

Team SIG Sauer's Lena Miculek fires a P365 and debates .380 vs 9mm.

VIDEO: SIG Sauer’s Lena Miculek Debates .380 Vs 9mm for Defense

The August-September 2022 issue of Ballistic Magazine is all about long-range.

The Ballistic Long-Range Precision Issue Bringing Long-Range Fire!

AMMO SPOTLIGHT

Testing the effective range of the .410 for hunting and survival.

So Just How Far is the Effective .410 Range for Hunting & Survival?

A few years ago I tested the American Tactical Imports (ATI) Omni Hybrid .410 shotgun for Ballistic Magazine. The shotgun...

site logo
The Premier Firearms & Survival Magazine

Tactical

  • tactical-life.com

Magazines

  • Tactical Life
  • The Complete Book of Reloading
  • Guns of the Old West

Facebook

  • Tactical-Life Facebook
  • Guns of the Old West Facebook

Twitter

  • Tactical-Life Twitter

Self Defense

  • PersonalDefenseWorld.com

Magazines

  • Personal Defense World
  • Combat Handguns

Facebook

  • Personal Defense World Facebook
  • Combat Handguns

Twitter

  • Personal Defense World Twitter

Shooting Lifestyle

  • BallisticMag.com

Magazines

  • Ballistic Magazine

Facebook

  • Ballistic Magazine Facebook

Twitter

  • Ballistic Magazine Twitter

Alpha Lifestyle

  • SkillsetMag.com

Magazines

  • Skillset

Facebook

  • Skillset Magazine Facebook

Twitter

  • Skillset Magazine Twitter

Instagram

  • Skillset Magazine Instagram
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Terms Of Use
  • Privacy Policy
© Athlon Outdoors, All Rights Reserved.
You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and awareness of the California Privacy Rights. Pursuant to U.S. Copyright law, as well as other applicable federal and state laws, the content on this website may not be reproduced, distributed, displayed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, without the prior, express, and written permission of Athlon Outdoors.

Manage your GDPR consents by clicking here. Manage your CCPA consents by clicking here.
No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • View All Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
      • Semi-Automatic Rifles
      • Bolt Action
      • Lever Action
    • Shotguns
    • Specialty Guns
    • Custom Guns
  • Ammo
    • Handgun Ammo
    • Rifle Ammo
  • Accessories
    • Suppressors
  • Gear
    • View All Gear
    • Knives
    • Storage
  • Lifestyle
    • View All Lifestyle
    • Training
    • Survival
    • Pop Culture
      • People
      • Rides
  • News
  • Videos
  • Subscribe

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.