Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • All
    • Class III & More
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    The New Original Henry Rifle.

    New Original Henry Rifle Kicks Off Cody Firearms Museum Collectors Series

    The compact 1895 Trapper should be a favorite with hunters.

    Marlin 1895 Trapper: The Iconic Lever-Gun in .45-70 Returns!

    The new Davidson's Dark Earth Cerakote Diamondback DBX brings upgrades.

    Davidson’s Launches Dark Earth Cerakote Diamondback DBX

    The Terminator Rifle build pays homage to a classic.

    This ’40w Plasma’ Terminator Rifle Build is Ready to Take on Skynet!

    The Winchester 88, introduced in 1955, was handsomely embellished with a hand-checkered diamond pattern stock and forend. The first models were chambered in .308 Winchester, the caliber in which most Model 88s are found today.

    Winchester Model 88: Rare, Valuable & Still Used in the Deer Woods

    We tested 12 compact and micro compact pistols to determine the best carry gun.

    Best Concealed Carry Pistols 2022: Compacts & Micros Dominate

    The Walther PDP F-Series was designed for women.

    VIDEO: The Walther PDP F-Series Completely Redefines ‘Women’s Gun’

    The Big Horn Armory AR500 Starter Kit includes 100 rounds of ammo.

    Big Horn Armory’s AR500 Starter Kit Brings Big-Bore Hunting Power

    Shooting the Mossberg MC2sc.

    Concealed Carry Powerhouse: The Mossberg MC2sc Delivers

  • Gear
    • All
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
    Federal Ammunition: The First Hundred Years celebrates the company anniversary.

    Federal Ammunition Celebrates 100 Years With Coffee Table Book

    300 Blackout vs 308, rifles, ammunition

    300 Blackout vs 308 Win: Which Round Reigns Supreme in AR-15s?

    The Big Horn Armory AR500 Starter Kit includes 100 rounds of ammo.

    Big Horn Armory’s AR500 Starter Kit Brings Big-Bore Hunting Power

    The Wicked Ridge Raider 400 is perfect for spring turkey season.

    Get on Turkeys Quietly With the Wicked Ridge Raider 400 Crossbow

    The Riflespeed Gas Control System gives user-control in the field.

    Riflespeed Gas Control System: Is This the Ultimate Recoil Management?

    The Vaultek Lifepod features a biometric lock.

    Vaultek LifePod XT Series: Keep Your Gear Safe & Secure in Any Weather

    The new Garmin Tactix 7 Series comes loaded with features.

    Garmin Tactix 7 Series: is this the Ultimate Smart Watch for Outdoorsmen?

    The author found the Walker Defense NERO extremely effective.

    VIDEO: The Walker Defense NERO Muzzle Brake Tames Beastly Recoil

    Trijicon REAP IR 60mm mini thermal riflescope, shooting bench, review

    Where Does the $9K Trijicon REAP IR 60mm Rank Amongst Riflescopes?

  • News
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • People
    • Podcasts
    • Rides
    • Survival
    • Tactics & Training
    A man open carries in a Walmart store.

    Mr. Manners: Let’s Have an Open Discussion on Open Carry

    Shit in the Woods, Wilderness pooping, toilet paper

    How to Poop in the Woods

    FUBeAR goes long-range in the April-May 2022 issue of Ballistic Magazine.

    Ballistic Magazine Mascot FUBeAR Goes Long-Range in April-May Issue

    Federal Ammunition: The First Hundred Years celebrates the company anniversary.

    Federal Ammunition Celebrates 100 Years With Coffee Table Book

    Follow these tips to catch more fish.

    Fish On: Use These Simple Lessons to Catch More Fish!

    Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting, pistol

    The Guide to Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting

    This turkey porn video should bring all the hunters to the yard.

    Extra, Extra … Get Your Hot, Wild Turkey Porn Here!?!

    Place rocks around your survival campfire.

    50 Survival Tips and Tricks for the Outdoors

    New video evidence suggests Alec Baldwin lied about pulling the trigger in fatal Rust shooting.

    Video Shows Alec Baldwin Held Finger on Trigger Before Fatal Shooting

  • Videos
    The Terminator Rifle build pays homage to a classic.

    This ’40w Plasma’ Terminator Rifle Build is Ready to Take on Skynet!

    This turkey porn video should bring all the hunters to the yard.

    Extra, Extra … Get Your Hot, Wild Turkey Porn Here!?!

    The Walther PDP F-Series was designed for women.

    VIDEO: The Walther PDP F-Series Completely Redefines ‘Women’s Gun’

    New video evidence suggests Alec Baldwin lied about pulling the trigger in fatal Rust shooting.

    Video Shows Alec Baldwin Held Finger on Trigger Before Fatal Shooting

    The Wicked Ridge Raider 400 is perfect for spring turkey season.

    Get on Turkeys Quietly With the Wicked Ridge Raider 400 Crossbow

    The Riflespeed Gas Control System gives user-control in the field.

    Riflespeed Gas Control System: Is This the Ultimate Recoil Management?

    The Vaultek Lifepod features a biometric lock.

    Vaultek LifePod XT Series: Keep Your Gear Safe & Secure in Any Weather

    The new Garmin Tactix 7 Series comes loaded with features.

    Garmin Tactix 7 Series: is this the Ultimate Smart Watch for Outdoorsmen?

    YouTube channel The Collector features $1M gun collection.

    The Collector: New YouTube Channel Shows Off $1M Gun Collection

  • More
    • Sweepstakes
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
  • Guns
    • All
    • Class III & More
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    The New Original Henry Rifle.

    New Original Henry Rifle Kicks Off Cody Firearms Museum Collectors Series

    The compact 1895 Trapper should be a favorite with hunters.

    Marlin 1895 Trapper: The Iconic Lever-Gun in .45-70 Returns!

    The new Davidson's Dark Earth Cerakote Diamondback DBX brings upgrades.

    Davidson’s Launches Dark Earth Cerakote Diamondback DBX

    The Terminator Rifle build pays homage to a classic.

    This ’40w Plasma’ Terminator Rifle Build is Ready to Take on Skynet!

    The Winchester 88, introduced in 1955, was handsomely embellished with a hand-checkered diamond pattern stock and forend. The first models were chambered in .308 Winchester, the caliber in which most Model 88s are found today.

    Winchester Model 88: Rare, Valuable & Still Used in the Deer Woods

    We tested 12 compact and micro compact pistols to determine the best carry gun.

    Best Concealed Carry Pistols 2022: Compacts & Micros Dominate

    The Walther PDP F-Series was designed for women.

    VIDEO: The Walther PDP F-Series Completely Redefines ‘Women’s Gun’

    The Big Horn Armory AR500 Starter Kit includes 100 rounds of ammo.

    Big Horn Armory’s AR500 Starter Kit Brings Big-Bore Hunting Power

    Shooting the Mossberg MC2sc.

    Concealed Carry Powerhouse: The Mossberg MC2sc Delivers

  • Gear
    • All
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
    Federal Ammunition: The First Hundred Years celebrates the company anniversary.

    Federal Ammunition Celebrates 100 Years With Coffee Table Book

    300 Blackout vs 308, rifles, ammunition

    300 Blackout vs 308 Win: Which Round Reigns Supreme in AR-15s?

    The Big Horn Armory AR500 Starter Kit includes 100 rounds of ammo.

    Big Horn Armory’s AR500 Starter Kit Brings Big-Bore Hunting Power

    The Wicked Ridge Raider 400 is perfect for spring turkey season.

    Get on Turkeys Quietly With the Wicked Ridge Raider 400 Crossbow

    The Riflespeed Gas Control System gives user-control in the field.

    Riflespeed Gas Control System: Is This the Ultimate Recoil Management?

    The Vaultek Lifepod features a biometric lock.

    Vaultek LifePod XT Series: Keep Your Gear Safe & Secure in Any Weather

    The new Garmin Tactix 7 Series comes loaded with features.

    Garmin Tactix 7 Series: is this the Ultimate Smart Watch for Outdoorsmen?

    The author found the Walker Defense NERO extremely effective.

    VIDEO: The Walker Defense NERO Muzzle Brake Tames Beastly Recoil

    Trijicon REAP IR 60mm mini thermal riflescope, shooting bench, review

    Where Does the $9K Trijicon REAP IR 60mm Rank Amongst Riflescopes?

  • News
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • People
    • Podcasts
    • Rides
    • Survival
    • Tactics & Training
    A man open carries in a Walmart store.

    Mr. Manners: Let’s Have an Open Discussion on Open Carry

    Shit in the Woods, Wilderness pooping, toilet paper

    How to Poop in the Woods

    FUBeAR goes long-range in the April-May 2022 issue of Ballistic Magazine.

    Ballistic Magazine Mascot FUBeAR Goes Long-Range in April-May Issue

    Federal Ammunition: The First Hundred Years celebrates the company anniversary.

    Federal Ammunition Celebrates 100 Years With Coffee Table Book

    Follow these tips to catch more fish.

    Fish On: Use These Simple Lessons to Catch More Fish!

    Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting, pistol

    The Guide to Cross-Eye Dominant Shooting

    This turkey porn video should bring all the hunters to the yard.

    Extra, Extra … Get Your Hot, Wild Turkey Porn Here!?!

    Place rocks around your survival campfire.

    50 Survival Tips and Tricks for the Outdoors

    New video evidence suggests Alec Baldwin lied about pulling the trigger in fatal Rust shooting.

    Video Shows Alec Baldwin Held Finger on Trigger Before Fatal Shooting

  • Videos
    The Terminator Rifle build pays homage to a classic.

    This ’40w Plasma’ Terminator Rifle Build is Ready to Take on Skynet!

    This turkey porn video should bring all the hunters to the yard.

    Extra, Extra … Get Your Hot, Wild Turkey Porn Here!?!

    The Walther PDP F-Series was designed for women.

    VIDEO: The Walther PDP F-Series Completely Redefines ‘Women’s Gun’

    New video evidence suggests Alec Baldwin lied about pulling the trigger in fatal Rust shooting.

    Video Shows Alec Baldwin Held Finger on Trigger Before Fatal Shooting

    The Wicked Ridge Raider 400 is perfect for spring turkey season.

    Get on Turkeys Quietly With the Wicked Ridge Raider 400 Crossbow

    The Riflespeed Gas Control System gives user-control in the field.

    Riflespeed Gas Control System: Is This the Ultimate Recoil Management?

    The Vaultek Lifepod features a biometric lock.

    Vaultek LifePod XT Series: Keep Your Gear Safe & Secure in Any Weather

    The new Garmin Tactix 7 Series comes loaded with features.

    Garmin Tactix 7 Series: is this the Ultimate Smart Watch for Outdoorsmen?

    YouTube channel The Collector features $1M gun collection.

    The Collector: New YouTube Channel Shows Off $1M Gun Collection

  • More
    • Sweepstakes
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Ballistic Magazine
No Result
View All Result

300 Blackout vs 308 vs 7.62×39: Which Caliber Is Best for Short Barrels?

Robert Jordan by Robert Jordan
June 23, 2021
in Ammo, Gear
0
300 Blackout vs 308 vs 7.62x39, 308 vs 7.62, best short barreled ammo
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
My editor recently relayed a question from a reader to me. Essentially, the question was, “What caliber is best for an AR pistol or short barreled rifle with say, a 10.5- to 12.5-inch barrel: 7.62x39mm, .300 Blackout, or .308?” That’s actually an important and well-thought out question. So let’s dive into the 300 Blackout vs 308 vs 7.62×39 debate as it relates to shorter barrels.

[in_content post=”3594″ alignment=”align-left” /]

The 300 Blackout vs 308 vs 7.62×39 in Short Barrels

First, they inquired about well-known and widely manufactured calibers. The Whatoozy 7000 may be the perfect caliber according to you, but if no one makes a wide variety of ammo for it, it’s useless for all but one or two purposes.

Next, how do we judge calibers? Velocity, accuracy, ballistic energy, or lethality? Short answer: Lethality. Short barrels are for deploying and maneuvering quickly. The other three criterion are important, but lethality trumps everything else. Side note: Ballistic energy—or foot pounds of energy—is NOT the same thing as lethality. Arrows are very lethal, yet have very low ballistic energy. I don’t have the ballistic gelatin or the testing facility of the FBI’s Ballistic Research and Development Lab, but I can make some pretty intuitive deductions based on the data available.

The Science

First, you need at least 2,500 fps to guarantee that the initial wound cavity causes permanent damage to the organs near the entry wound. Otherwise, even though the initial wound cavity may look cool in ballistic gelatin, it is not enough to cause any real damage. Our organs are amazingly elastic and resilient. Some experts say you need 3,000 fps because the bullet rapidly slows down after it leaves the muzzle and it needs to be at 2,500 or greater when it hits the body. They have a point.

The FBI and a lot of other experts are the ones that figured out about 2,500 fps. Interestingly, way back during the Army “Pig Board” in the late 1920s, they came to the same conclusion. They just didn’t understand all of the “why.” They saw that a smaller, faster round did far more damage to pigs—both living and dead—than a bigger, slower round. These tests eventually would lead to the military dropping the .30 caliber rifles in favor of the M16 decades later.

7.62x39mm

OK, back to the original question and picking a caliber. Firstly, let’s start with 7.62x39mm—the round of the venerable AK-47. Is it lethal? I just heard more than one million groans from the grave tell me it is, but only due to abundance. Go buy some 7.62 ammo. Do you want full metal jacket or hollow-point? Next you can pick what country it was made in. That’s it. There are a few soft-point, hunting rounds, but no one is touting this round for being the best to kill deer, moose, or elk; there is a reason for that.

Pass on 7.62, especially in a short barrel. You will usually be getting 2,300 to 2,400 fps in a 16.3-inch barrel; that isn’t great for lethality. On the plus side, you can drop the barrel length down to  around 11 inches and you will only be losing about 150 to 200 fps. Not bad, but 7.62x39mm doesn’t have a high enough velocity, even with a full-length barrel.

300 Blackout

Next comes .300 Blackout. A .30 caliber bullet coming from an AR-15 (not AR-10) platform and able to come out in regular or subsonic (for suppressed weapons) velocities? Sounds awesome! Here is a round that can be had in lots of different configurations. There are different bullet sizes, designs, and velocities. Everything sounds great until you start talking to the experts who actually test these rounds. And .300 Blackout in subsonic is crap dot poop. It has the same lethality of a pistol round. You can shoot a sub-gun in 9mm or .45 ACP and be just as effective. Rounds have to go in excess of 2,500 fps for the initial wound cavity to cause damage to periphery organs. Otherwise they just absorb the shock and keep on functioning. Subsonic rounds all suck … equally. I grew up beating the drum for .45, so this hurts me as much as anyone.

While .300 Blackout in supersonic fares far better, it still doesn’t get us up to the magical 2,500 fps unless you INCREASE the barrel length to about 20 inches or more. And remember, the bullet needs to be going at least 2,500 fps when it hits the target, not when it exits the muzzle. Not surprisingly, most hunters who use the .300 Blackout extensively will tell you the same thing, without even knowing about the 2,500 fps rule: The round just doesn’t deliver when it comes to killing. It pokes holes, but it doesn’t drop them the way other calibers do.

.308

So let’s talk about the venerable .308. Most .308 ammo sits around 2,500 fps in a 16-inch barrel. If you drop the ammo down to a lighter size, say a 147gr, you can keep it above 2,500 fps down to a 13-inch barrel (barely). Once you get down to 10.5 inches, you are typically in the 2,100 to 2,200 fps realm. You are beating 7.62 and .300 Blackout, but it still isn’t enough to do much more than poke holes in bad guys. Yes, bullet tumble and yaw help increase lethality, but are so hard to predict that I am not bringing it into this discussion.

Highest Velocity?

I know what you are thinking. Let’s just go with the highest velocity round they make; that will be the best. Well, it’s a good thought, but it isn’t that simple. The 5.7mm is an amazing pistol round. It can be made to beat the 2,500 fps in a pistol length barrel, but the rounds available have been ice picks. Without any expansion, they don’t give us that nice initial wound cavity either.

But it’s an exciting time to be alive. I saw Speer Gold Dot this year announced it is releasing rifle rounds (.223, .308, and .300 Blackout; see below) that function like pistol rounds. They open up and peel back like all of those beautiful bullets that pass the FBI pistol tests (typically Speer Gold Dot, Federal Hydra-Shok, and Hornady Critical Duty). They may not cause as much periphery damage as a round going more than 2,500 fps, but they may prove better than the match ammo and hunting rounds we have been using in the past. Jury is still out on that one.

The Ideal Length

Finally, let’s find an answer to the original question. You want a 10.5- to 12.5-inch barreled AR in the most lethal caliber. I’ve been told over and over by my agency that I should stick to a 16-inch barrel because it works better. They are wrong.

Anyone who has cleared a meth head’s single wide stacked with shit to the ceiling will tell you that a 16-inch barrel is too long. Anyone who has tried to yank out a carbine from their passenger seat during a takedown at Home Depot parking lot will tell you a 16-inch barrel is too long. I agree with you—10.5 inches to 12.5 inches is the ideal length.

The Winner

So what do I recommend? The 5.56mm in a 12.5-inch barrel. Curve ball! And oh how it pains me to say it. But that is actually what I am carrying on duty these days. I know, 5.56mm is a mouse round! It has half of the ballistic energy of the .308 in the same length barrel. But it also performs better for maximizing damage over the ones we talked about above. M855 (Green Tip 55gr) ammo is still singing out there at more than 2,500 fps from an 11-inch barrel. And no, I don’t recommend Green Tip for self defense; it acts too much like an ice pick. Heavier, 69gr rounds tend to drop below 2,500 fps in barrels between 12 and 13 inches. But there are lots of lighter, fast 5.56mm rounds that are soft or plastic-tipped and they cook.

My second choice would be .308. Third would be .300 Blackout. Meanwhile, 7.62×39 would come in last, just because of the lack bullet varieties. Behind these would be a pistol caliber. I’m not wholly dismissing pistol calibers—they are loads of fun and you can do super fast follow-up shots—but look at the ER statistics. According to ERs, only about 10 percent of handgun victims die. That number jumps up rapidly when it comes to people shot by rifle rounds. I don’t have the exact stat in front of me, but I think it was nearing 40 percent.

You’re probably wondering what I keep at home for self defense? A 12 gauge with 1-ounce slugs. But that is a whole different topic.

Didn't find what you were looking for?

CLICK HERE FOR COMMENTS

Related Posts

300 Blackout vs 308, rifles, ammunition

300 Blackout vs 308 Win: Which Round Reigns Supreme in AR-15s?

The Savage 110 Carbon Tactical shaves weight with a Proof Research barrel.

Savage 110 Carbon Tactical Brings Lightweight, Long-Range Powerhouse

The Nosler Model 21 Rifle.

The New Nosler Model 21 Lightweight Hunting Rifle Features Custom Feel

The True Velocity commemorative ammunition box set

True Velocity: Composite-Cased Ammunition Now Commercially Available

Load More

Discussion about this post

FEATURED POST

A man open carries in a Walmart store.

Mr. Manners: Let’s Have an Open Discussion on Open Carry

by Fred Mastison
May 18, 2022
0

You walk into your local grocery store and immediately see an intense discussion going on. There...

Read more

TRENDING

A man open carries in a Walmart store.

Mr. Manners: Let’s Have an Open Discussion on Open Carry

You walk into your local grocery store and immediately see an intense discussion...

The New Original Henry Rifle.

New Original Henry Rifle Kicks Off Cody Firearms Museum Collectors Series

Henry Repeating Arms, in partnership with Baron Engraving and Davidson's Inc., just launched...

The compact 1895 Trapper should be a favorite with hunters.

Marlin 1895 Trapper: The Iconic Lever-Gun in .45-70 Returns!

Long live the lever-gun! Marlin made a big announcement today, marking the return...

Shit in the Woods, Wilderness pooping, toilet paper

How to Poop in the Woods

Bears do it, why shouldn't you? Yes, we're very literally talking about pooping...

PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT

Montana Mega Mansion, Indoor Shooting Range, two lanes

$14M Montana Mega Mansion for Sale Has an Indoor Shooting Range

Update: The Montana Mega Mansion sold on March 18, 2021, for an undisclosed amount of money. Must be nice to...

PRODUCT SHOWCASE: ATHLON OUTDOORS RENDEZVOUS

A man open carries in a Walmart store.

Mr. Manners: Let’s Have an Open Discussion on Open Carry

The New Original Henry Rifle.

New Original Henry Rifle Kicks Off Cody Firearms Museum Collectors Series

The compact 1895 Trapper should be a favorite with hunters.

Marlin 1895 Trapper: The Iconic Lever-Gun in .45-70 Returns!

Shit in the Woods, Wilderness pooping, toilet paper

How to Poop in the Woods

FUBeAR goes long-range in the April-May 2022 issue of Ballistic Magazine.

Ballistic Magazine Mascot FUBeAR Goes Long-Range in April-May Issue

site logo
The Premier Firearms & Survival Magazine
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Terms Of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • California Privacy Notice
  • Cookie Policy
© Athlon Outdoors, All Rights Reserved.
You use of this website constitutes and manifests your acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and awareness of the California Privacy Rights. Pursuant to U.S. Copyright law, as well as other applicable federal and state laws, the content on this website may not be reproduced, distributed, displayed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, without the prior, express, and written permission of Athlon Outdoors.

Manage your GDPR consents by clicking here. Manage your CCPA consents by clicking here.
No Result
View All Result
  • Guns
    • View All Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Class III & More
    • Sponsored
      • SIG Sauer
  • Gear
    • View All Gear
    • Accessories
    • Ammo
    • Knives
    • Suppressors
  • Videos
    • Free Gun Friday
  • More
    • Sweepstakes
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
  • News
  • View All Lifestyle
  • People
  • Podcasts
  • Rides
  • Survival
  • Tactics & Training

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.